· 3 min read

Is P90X2 better than P90X? First impressions

P90XP90X2

I started P90X2 a few weeks ago, so I am still in Phase 1. So far, so great, so let me answer some common questions about the program.

  1. Does P90X2 replace P90X?
    NO! P90X is still for sale, because it is still a great workout program. It's the workout program that saved my life, in fact, as I struggled with weight and fitness. P90X set me on the path to good nutrition and exercise.
  2. Is P90X2 harder than P90X?
    That's a tricky one, and I am tempted to say yes, because P90X2 involves a lot of balancing. We work out a lot with a stability ball, for example, doing one-handed chest presses with my back balanced on the ball, pelvis up, feet on the floor. That requires a lot of extra balance and muscular coordination than doing a simple press from a bench. Also, pushup-to-one-arm-balance with hands on medicine balls is quite challenging.... Okay, screw it, YES, P90X2 is harder!
  3. Should I do P90X first, then do P90X2?
    Well, I just said P90X2 is harder, so you might think it makes more sense to do P90X first, but I don't think it really matters much. Would you do better during X2 if you did The X first? Sure. And vice versa.
  4. Is the structure of P90X2 different than P90X?
    • It is a bit different, but not really too much. With P90X2 you only need to press play 5 days a week. You can either do the "Recovery & Mobility" workout or simply rest on Days 3 and 7.
    • X2 is not as rigid as The X is, with X's 3-weeks-on-one-week-recovery formula. X2 is divided into 3 phases -- Phase 1: Core, Phase 2: Strength, and Phase 3: Performance. You can make Phases 1 and 2 anywhere from 3 to 6 weeks, and Phase 3 should last 3 to 4 weeks. There is a Recovery Week that you can "do whenever you want". You can do it between phases, in the middle of phases, or just skip it altogether. I wouldn't recommend that, though. Just listen to your body.
    • If you did The X, you know we worked that "Ab Ripper" workout 3 days a week. In X2, it's only that often during Phase 2. Ab Ripper is only 1 day during Phase 1 and it's not in Phase 3 at all.
    • The workouts are still about an hour long, and Ab Ripper is still about 15 minutes. Yoga is about an hour (not 90 minutes as it was in P90X). Remember, I am only a week in, so  we'll have to see about the later workouts.
    • Oh, also, if you buy anything but the basic package, you will get some additional workouts on DVD that you can substitute in to ease boredom and add muscle confusion.
  5. Do you need to be in shape to do X2? How is the Fit Test different from P90X's Fit Test?
    The Fit Test for P90X2 is the same one as for P90X. However, I started P90X a few years ago without passing the pullups part of the Fit Test, and I know others who have started it without passing much of the Fit Test at all. Those people understood that they needed to take the exercise very slowly and eat right to build up to the point where they could do the workouts properly. If you take it easy and don't hurt yourself, couch potatoes can start one of these programs, but a program like Power 90 might be the way to start, then go for one of the more advanced ones.
  6. Is there a vegan nutrition guide for P90X2?
    Yes, there is! X2 comes with several nutrition paths, including vegan.
  7. If I've done P90X, do I really need to do P90X2?
    If you are happy with P90X and the results you continue to get from it, then you can stick with it. But if you are looking for a new challenge -- and aren't we all? -- you should definitely give P90X2 a try.

I really like P90X2 so far. I enjoy the difficulty of balancing on balls to do moves that previously seemed pretty easy. Better than P90X? You will think this is a cop out, but it's true: They are both great, but different.

If you would like to order P90X2, please click any of the links on this page. If you have questions, reach me through my contact page for more information. Take control of your fitness!

Related reading

  1. · Exercise, P90X

    Why Beachbody? Here's my story.

    Today on Facebook I read a conversation about Beachbody. I took a screenshot and it's the graphic you see with this post. The tone of the conversation was not a bit sarcastic, but, although I love me some…

  2. · Exercise, P90X

    Is P90X2 better than P90X? (Part 2)

    I'm in Phase 2 of P90X2 now, so I thought I'd give you my second set of impressions of how X2 compares to the original X. While both are great programs that will get you into shape, my mind has changed a bit since my initial thoughts.

  3. · Exercise, P90X

    The Difference between P90X and P90X2 -- by Tony Horton

    In this short video, Tony Horton -- the creator of P90X and P90X2 -- explains the difference between the two programs. If you don't want to watch the video, the upshot is that P90X gets you into shape,…